Friday, 19 September 2025

Particles with Personalities

In popular accounts of physics, particles rarely sit quietly. Quarks “carry colour.” Electrons “want” stability. Neutrinos “refuse” to interact. The subatomic world, it seems, is populated by temperamental beings with hobbies, quirks, and strong personal preferences.

This is a charming way to describe physics — but it’s also a metaphorical trap. By attributing agency and character to particles, we mislead ourselves about what particles are and how they relate.


The Subatomic Soap Opera

Physics classrooms and documentaries often cast particles as social actors:

  • Quarks are painted as extroverts with flamboyant “colours,” constantly forming cliques (protons, neutrons).

  • Electrons are the needy ones, forever “seeking” stability in orbitals, sometimes “jealous” of their neighbours.

  • Neutrinos play the aloof loners, drifting through matter as if ignoring everyone at the party.

The atom becomes less a structure of relations and more a soap opera ensemble cast.


Why This Is Misleading

These personality metaphors obscure the reality that particles are not tiny agents but relational nodes in a field of interaction. To say an electron “wants stability” is to confuse statistical regularities of distribution with human desire. To say quarks “carry colour” is to borrow an everyday visual metaphor for something utterly abstract and mathematical.

The danger is that students, readers, and even researchers internalise these fictions as if they were features of reality. The atom becomes populated not by patterns but by characters — leading to ontological confusion.


Relational Ontology Footnote

Relational ontology helps clear the stage. Particles are not actors with motives, but phenomena construed in terms of patterned relations — distributions, constraints, and systemic alignments. The so-called “colour” of quarks or “desire” of electrons are metaphors attempting to render abstract relations intelligible, but when taken literally, they smuggle anthropomorphic agency into the fabric of matter.


Closing Joke (Because Parody)

If subatomic particles truly had personalities, the periodic table would be less a classification of elements and more a yearbook:

  • Hydrogen: Most Likely to Bond

  • Helium: Doesn’t Need Anyone

  • Uranium: Has Anger Issues

Physics would collapse into gossip, and the Large Hadron Collider would need a therapist, not a detector.

No comments:

Post a Comment