Metaphor: The universe expanding like a balloon, with galaxies as dots moving apart as the balloon inflates.
Problem: This metaphor suggests a centre and an edge, implying expansion into some pre-existing space. It misleads by projecting human-scale, tangible intuition onto a relational, scale-free phenomenon. The universe does not inflate into anything; it is the space that is expanding.
Relational ontology: Expansion is relational scaling of distances between matter-energy potentials. Galaxies drift apart not because a balloon stretches, but because the relational field itself evolves. There is no “outside” to inflate into.
Parody punchline: If the universe were a balloon, cosmologists would need cosmic helium, and the Big Bang would be a party trick gone horribly wrong.
No comments:
Post a Comment